End Garda Politicking on Prostitution and Stop Garda Abuse of People in Sex Work
Lucy Smyth, of UglyMugs.ie, who started the petition, said she did so after her attention was drawn to an announcement that the Garda Organised Prostitution Investigation Unit was due to speak at a ‘A Model for Scotland’ lobbying event on 23 February. An Garda Síochána is an apolitical organisation and should not be speaking at lobbying events.
Sex work was further criminalised in Ireland most recently through the Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Act 2017, following a successful lobbying campaign by the Turn Off the Red Light (TORL) coalition. Since the 2017 legislative changes in Ireland crime against people in sex work has increased by 91% and violent crime specifically has increased by 92%. Last month Amnesty International published a report showing how the 2017 law has facilitated the targeting and abuse of sex workers, the state is failing to protect them from violence and they now have a profound lack
of trust in the Gardaí.
“Sex workers in Ireland have suffered greatly because of the TORL campaign supported by the Gardaí. I don’t want to see the same happen to sex workers in Scotland.” said Lucy Smyth.
Speaking for the first time about her own personal experience of Garda conduct during the TORL campaign, Lucy Smyth said “At that time members of the Gardaí told me that the reason they were supporting TORL is because the people running TORL were very powerful, and Gardaí were being offered benefits in exchange for their support. I was told that these benefits were not financial payments but rather things like promotion opportunities.”
“Reflecting on this now I think there is an internationally recognised term for what that is. It is Grand Corruption, the abuse of high-level power that benefits the few at the expense of the many. I also feel like, in Ireland, Grand Corruption could be seen as something of a double entendre, because I think a lot of people in power regard harming certain marginalised groups as ‘grand’, as in nothing to be too bothered about. But it is not ‘grand’, it causes huge harm.”
“I also want to say that during the TORL campaign I personally suffered a great deal of abuse at the hands of members of the Gardaí which devastated my life. I used to be quite outspoken, but, for a long time now, the trauma of what happened here has almost completely silenced me. But I want to say this now. I want to stand with people who have experienced or are experiencing Garda abuse and say yes, this is my experience too.“
“I implore the Garda Commissioner to think of the future well-being of people in sex work and victims of sex trafficking. The Gardaí have failed to address any of the very serious issues around their policing of sex work and sex trafficking for a great many years. The serious problem of garda members abusing people in sex work and sex trafficking, in particular abuse of power for sexual gain, is also not being addressed. This is causing huge harm to human beings and things will not improve here without Garda leaders taking action.”
For a copy of this press release with references please see: